Employee vs contractors: new rules

Grahame Allen • January 19, 2024

Following on from two prominent High Court decisions in Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union v Personnel Contracting Pty Ltd [2022] HCA 1 and ZG Operations Australia Pty Ltd v Jamsek [2022] HCA 2, the ATO has issued a Ruling clarifying the issue of whether certain individuals are employees or independent contractors. In brief, the High Court’s decisions deal with the distinction between employees and independent contractors in the context of a labour hire company and two truck drivers operating through partnerships to provide delivery services to their former employer. In the first case, the High Court ruled that a labourer engaged by a labour hire company to work on construction sites under the supervision and control of a builder was an employee of the labour hire company. The High Court noted that this right of control, and the ability to supply a compliant workforce, was the key asset of the business as a labour-hire agency and constituted an employment relationship. That the parties chose the label "contractor" to describe the labourer did not change the character of that relationship, the High Court said. This decision also overruled a earlier Full Federal Court decision which held that the labourer was an independent contractor after applying a ”multifactorial approach”. In the second case, the High Court held that two truck drivers were not employees of a company for the purposes of the Fair Work Act 2009 and Superannuation Guarantee (Administration) Act 1992. The Court also observed that the provision of such services has consistently been held, both in Australia and in England, to have been characteristic of independent contractors (and not employees). In the present case, the High Court said there was no reason to reach a different conclusion. Due to these landmark High Court decisions, the ATO has now released Taxation Ruling TR 2023/4 which states that whether an individual (ie worker) is an employee of an entity (“engaging entity”) under the term's ordinary meaning is a question of fact to be determined by reference to an objective assessment of the totality of the relationship between the parties, having regard only to the legal rights and obligations which constitute that relationship. In addition, where the worker and the engaging entity have comprehensively committed the terms of their relationship to a written contract and the validity of that contract has not been challenged as a sham, nor have the terms of the contract otherwise been varied, waived, discharged or the subject of an estoppel or any equitable, legal or statutory right or remedy, it is the legal rights and obligations in the contract alone that are relevant in determining whether the worker is an employee of an engaging entity. The Ruling notes that evidence of how the contract was performed including subsequent conduct and work practices cannot be considered for the purpose of determining the nature of the legal relationship between the parties. However, this evidence can be considered to establish the contractual terms or to challenge the validity of a written contract with general contract law principles. It should be noted that the Ruling now states that the various indicia of employment that have been identified in case law (ie control and right to control, ability to delegate subcontract or assign work, achieve a specified result, bearer of risk, or generation of goodwill) remain relevant, but are only to be considered in respect of the legal rights and obligations between the parties. Therefore, according to the Ruling, the most important factor is the holistic consideration of the contract between the parties to determine whether, on balance, the worker is an employee or independent contractor. This requires an approach which involves standing back and viewing the contract from a distance such that an informed, considered, qualitative appreciation of the whole can be undertaken. In conjunction with the Ruling, the ATO has also released a Practical Compliance Guideline (PCG 2023/2) which sets out its compliance approach for businesses that engage workers and classify them as employees or independent contractors.

Accessing super from age 60 to 65

By Grahame Allen • August 30, 2024
From 1 July 2024, the rules for accessing superannuation became somewhat simplified: the preservation age when you can begin to access your benefits is now effectively age 60. However, until you reach age 65, there are still potential restrictions on how you can access your super. You’ll need to “retire” before you can make lump sum withdrawals from your super account or move it into the favourable “retirement phase” when investment earnings within the fund become tax-free. If you’re aged between 60 and 65 and wish to access some of your super, now is a good time to re-examine the rules. 60 is the new threshold For anyone born after 30 June 1964, preservation age is simply age 60. You may recall that some members could previously begin to access their superannuation at various stages between 55 and 59 years. Those lower preservation ages applied for older Australians who are now all over 60 and who have already attained their preservation age. Therefore, those rules regarding ages 55 to 59 are no longer an active consideration. How much super can I access? If you are between 60 and 65 years old but haven’t yet retired, you can commence a transition to retirement income stream (TRIS). This allows you to receive a regular income of between 4% and 10% of your pension account balance each year. If you want to access more of your super, or withdraw it as a lump sum, you’ll need to satisfy a further condition of release. This includes: reaching age 65; or “retirement”. Meeting these conditions also becomes relevant for tax purposes. While TRIS payments to a person aged 60 or over are generally tax-free – regardless of whether they are retired or not – the TRIS itself does not move into the “retirement phase” until a further condition such as retirement (or reaching age 65) is met. This means that while you may start a TRIS, the TRIS will not qualify for the tax exemption on the investment earnings from fund assets that support the TRIS until you meet one of those further conditions. What does “retirement” mean? To satisfy the “retirement” condition, the first key requirement is that an arrangement under which you were gainfully employed must have come to an end. If you had already reached age 60 when that position of gainful employment ended, there are no further requirements, and your future work intentions are not relevant. However, if you had not yet reached aged 60 when that position ended, the trustee of your fund must be reasonably satisfied that you intend never to again become gainfully employed, either on a full-time or a part-time basis. For these purposes, “part-time” means working for at least 10 hours per week. This means you could intend to work for less than 10 hours per week and still meet the “retirement” condition. Planning is key Any withdrawal strategy should be carefully planned beforehand to ensure you understand the implications of accessing your super. There are many factors to consider, such as: the ongoing requirement to withdraw minimum pension amounts each year if you start a pension; implications for your transfer balance account; and interaction with the Age Pension. Contact our office if you need help understanding your eligibility for accessing your super, or to begin a discussion about your long-term retirement planning.

Super guarantee a focus area for ATO business debt collection

By Grahame Allen • August 16, 2024
The ATO has revealed its focus areas for this year, with business debt collection identified as a key strategic priority. In its Corporate Plan 2024–25, the ATO says that it will have “an increased focus on business debt including superannuation guarantee, pay as you go withholding and goods and services tax”. This is a timely reminder for all businesses to ensure they’re meeting their obligations. Superannuation guarantee (SG) remains an important compliance focus. The most recent ATO statistics show that although 94% of employers are meeting their SG obligations without ATO intervention, the ATO still raised over $1 billion in SG charge liabilities in the 2022–23 financial year. That figure reflects a lot of extra super liability for Australian businesses that could have been avoided if they had paid the required SG contributions on time. To ensure your business doesn’t incur these extra liabilities, you must pay SG contributions for your employees and eligible contractors on time and to the correct fund. The quarterly due dates are as follows: Q1 (1 July – 30 September): 28 October; Q2 (1 October – 31 December): 28 January; Q3 (1 January – 31 March): 28 April; and Q4 (1 April – 30 June): 28 July. Some important things to remember include: Some contracts and awards may require you to pay contributions more regularly than quarterly. If you make contributions to a commercial “clearing house”, the contribution is considered to be paid when it’s received by the employee’s fund, not by the clearing house. However, if you use the ATO’s Small Business Superannuation Clearing House, the contribution is “paid” when received by that clearing house. From 1 July 2026, employers will need to pay SG at the same time as salary and wages (commonly known as “payday super”). What if my business misses an SG payment? Taking action promptly is essential to accessing the ATO’s support services and minimising your exposure to penalties. The ATO says that it’s willing to work with employers who want to put things right. When you miss a payment, you must lodge an SG charge statement with the ATO within one month of the missed quarterly due date. Lodging on time is important, as failing to do so will incur a further penalty known as a “part 7 penalty”, which can be up to 200% of your SG charge liabilities. Also, when you lodge on time, you may then be able to set up a payment plan to pay your liabilities in instalments. You can ask the ATO for an extension to the lodgement date, but you must do this before the due date. You’ll also need to pay the SG charge. This charge is more than the amount of contributions you would have paid if you had paid them on time, and it’s not deductible. The charge comprises: the amount of the missed contributions (but calculated on salary and wages, including overtime, which is more than the usual “ordinary time earnings” basis for on-time SG contributions); interest of 10% pa (which accrues from the start of the relevant quarter); and an administration fee of $20 per employee, per quarter. This is paid to the ATO, not your employee’s fund. General interest charge will accrue on any outstanding SG charge, and the ATO may also issue a director penalty notice if it remains unpaid. We’re here to help Mistakes happen, but getting on top of problems early will lead to a better outcome for your business. Contact our office for expert assistance in addressing your business’s SG obligations.

Claiming the tax-free threshold: getting it right

By Grahame Allen • August 9, 2024
If you’re an Australian resident for tax purposes, you don’t have to pay income tax on the first $18,200 you earn each year, from any source. This is called the “tax-free threshold”. If you have multiple income sources, it’s important to consider which one you’ll claim it for. The ATO advises claiming the tax-free threshold once from your “main” payer – typically the job, gig or payment that pays you the most during the year. That payer will not withhold income tax from the first $18,200 they pay you but will withhold tax from payments once your earnings go over the threshold. At the end of the financial year, the ATO calculates your total income and tax withheld. If not enough tax has been withheld, you can expect a tax bill. If more tax has been withheld than you owe for your total earnings, you can expect a refund. Claim the tax-free threshold When starting a new job, your employer should ask you to complete a withholding declaration. To claim the tax-free threshold, you must be an Australian resident for tax purposes on the declaration and answer “yes” to the question “Do you want to claim the tax-free threshold from this payer?”. Where you answer “no”, tax will be withheld from all income from that payer. Avoid claiming the threshold from multiple payers simultaneously unless you’re sure you’ll earn less than $18,200 total for the year. Overclaiming might make your take-home pay higher each pay cycle but will likely mean a tax debt later. Changing jobs When changing jobs you can claim the threshold from your new payer even if you have claimed it from your previous one. If you add a job or side gig that will provide more income than your existing main payer, you can change your claim at any time. Altering your tax-free threshold claim Change your claim using ATO online services, via your myGov account: Sign in to myGov and access ATO online services Select Employment from the menu Choose either New employment (for a new job) or Employment details (for an existing employer) Update your tax and super details as needed. Don’t forget your side gig If you’re earning income outside of employment (eg as a sole trader) you’ll need to pay tax yourself on that income. Consider setting aside a percentage for tax or using pay as you go (PAYG) instalments each time you are paid.
More Posts
Share by: